When Your New Car Becomes a Safety Recall, Who Protects the Customer?
When Your New Car Becomes a Safety Recall, Who Protects the Customer?
Opinion: The recent Chery recall raises important questions, not only about one brand, but about the entire motor industry and the responsibility manufacturers have towards their customers.
A vehicle is one of the biggest financial commitments most South Africans will make. We buy it expecting reliability, safety and peace of mind. But what happens when the manufacturer tells you that the vehicle you have been driving may have a potentially serious manufacturing defect?
The recall in question
According to the National Consumer Commission (NCC), 23,667 vehicles are affected by the recall announced on 10 November 2026. These include the Chery Tiggo 4, Omoda C5 and Chery Tiggo 8 Pro Max 2.0.
The reported issues include potential welding irregularities on rear axle sleeves, which could result in the axle becoming detached and the rear suspension collapsing. Certain Tiggo 8 Pro Max 2.0 vehicles also face a separate issue involving a brake pipe that could wear against the turbocharger assembly, potentially resulting in brake-fluid leakage and reduced braking performance.
The NCC has also confirmed that it is investigating allegations that certain previous recalls were conducted without notifying the Commission.
Let's be clear: this is not a minor infotainment glitch or a faulty window switch. These are components that play a fundamental role in keeping a vehicle on the road and allowing it to stop safely. That brings us to five questions every prospective and existing vehicle owner should be asking.
1. Would you still be happy owning the vehicle?
Imagine buying a brand-new vehicle, travelling with your family and children, and then discovering that the rear axle could potentially separate from the vehicle because of a welding irregularity. Would you climb back in with the same confidence? Even if the manufacturer offers a free repair, the psychological impact cannot simply be repaired with a spanner and a replacement component.
A recall is an important safety mechanism, and manufacturers must be commended when they take responsibility and rectify identified defects. But the customer should not be expected to carry the burden of uncertainty. Manufacturers need to explain exactly what went wrong, what corrective work will be undertaken, how the repair will be verified and what guarantees will be provided afterwards. A simple notification that your vehicle needs to be inspected is not enough when the potential consequences involve loss of control or suspension failure.
2. Is the infrastructure there to repair almost 24,000 vehicles properly?
It is one thing to sell thousands of vehicles in South Africa. It is quite another to have the infrastructure, technicians, specialised equipment, replacement parts and quality-control systems to support those vehicles throughout their lifespan. A recall involving potentially defective structural welding is not a routine service.
Can every authorised dealership perform the necessary inspection and repair to the required engineering standard? Are sufficient replacement components available locally? How long will customers wait, and will courtesy vehicles be provided? These are legitimate questions, particularly when Business Day previously reported on a Chery customer whose vehicle had been off the road for five months because of replacement-parts delays. That report does not prove the recall cannot be managed, but it highlights why parts availability and after-sales capacity deserve serious scrutiny. Selling vehicles is the beginning of the customer relationship, not the end of it.
3. What exactly happened to the rear axle welding?
Photographs circulating online appear to show rear suspension and axle welding failures, although not every photograph on social media should be treated as independently verified evidence. The underlying engineering question remains extremely important. Was this a problem with the welding process, the materials, quality control or the design? Was it limited to a particular production batch? And most importantly, what independent engineering verification will confirm that the corrective work has permanently addressed the problem? Customers deserve a clear technical explanation, not simply reassurance that everything is fine.
4. What happens to resale and trade-in values?
This is where the financial consequences for customers could become particularly unpleasant. Consider the Ford Kuga, whose recall became a significant reputational issue in South Africa, with owners experiencing difficulties when disposing of their vehicles. Trade-in offers reportedly as low as 50% of expected trade value have been heard of. Individual experiences are not a universal market valuation, but they illustrate the financial anxiety that follows a major safety controversy.
There is no reliable evidence yet to quantify the impact this recall will have on resale values. But if a dealer checks a vehicle's history and finds it was part of a major safety recall, will the next buyer be comfortable? Will finance houses and insurers view the vehicle differently? The customer should not be the person who suffers financially because of a manufacturing problem outside their control.
5. What protection does the Consumer Protection Act offer?
South Africa's Consumer Protection Act (CPA) provides important protections when goods are unsafe, defective or fail to meet acceptable quality standards. Section 55 deals with the right to goods that are reasonably suitable for their intended purpose, of good quality and free of defects. Section 56 provides an implied warranty of quality: within six months of delivery, if goods fail those requirements, the consumer may return them at the supplier's risk and expense and direct the supplier to repair, replace or refund. Section 56(3) goes further: if a repaired defect remains, or a further defect or unsafe feature appears within three months of the repair, the supplier must replace the goods or refund the purchase price. Section 60 deals with safety monitoring and recalls, and section 61 provides for liability for certain harm caused by unsafe goods.
However, a recall does not automatically entitle every owner to a new vehicle or a refund. The application of these rights depends on the circumstances, the nature of the defect, the timing and the available legal remedies. Whether customers whose vehicles are older than six months have sufficient practical protection against the financial consequences is a question that deserves proper attention from the NCC and the wider industry.
Final thoughts
This is not about whether Chinese vehicles are good or bad. Chinese manufacturers have become an important part of the South African market, bringing competition, technology, equipment and more affordable choices. Competition is good for the customer, but competition must come with accountability.
A vehicle is not a disposable consumer product. It is something families rely on every day, often travelling at highway speeds with their most precious possessions inside. When something goes wrong with the manufacturing of a vehicle, who ultimately carries the cost: the manufacturer who built it, or the customer who trusted them enough to buy it? A manufacturer's responsibility should not end when the vehicle leaves the showroom. It should continue for as long as that vehicle carries its badge.
